By Greggory Moore
The last of several forums for candidates running for the Second District City Council seat was put on by the East Village Arts District on May 24 in the Grand Salon of the Cooper Arms building. This piece will not pretend to be any sort of comprehensive coverage. This was my first exposure to some of the candidates. Furthermore, parts of some of their answers were swallowed up (from where I was sitting, at least) by the aesthetically pleasing but echo-heavy room. I can hope for little more than to pass along my impressions.
The evening began promptly at 7 p.m. in front of around 70 people. The candidates present were (in alphabetical order): Becky Blair, Sonny Bozeman, Hank Conn, Richard Green, Thomas Herzog, Suja Lowenthal, Bry Myown, Lyle Sardie, Brian Ulaszewski, and Gabrielle Weeks. Each was allowed a short opening statement, then consecutively asked to address the same three issues: to name the last three businesses within the Second District they had patronized, to name a specific Second District artist they’d supported, and to address any conflict of interest they might encounter if elected. Frankly, the answers to the first two questions were not particularly informative: all could name three businesses (Portfolio got the most mentions (it is great)), and most everyone could name at least one artist—none of which could be verified (which is not to say I suspect anyone of fabricating his or her answers). Answers to the third question, however, provided what I found to be some of the evening’s most interesting moments. Several of the candidates mentioned that they owned property within the District and that this meant they would have to abstain from voting on any project taking place within 500 feet of their property. But in his turn, Herzog called Lowenthal and Blair on the carpet for not addressing what he considered big conflicts of interest: for Lowenthal, the presence of her mother-in-law (Bonnie Lowenthal) on the City Council; for Blair, that she is president of Blair Commercial Real Estate, a company heavily involved in property deals throughout the city. (I am told that Blair said that if elected she will pass on her company to her nephew.) Most of the audience seemed to agree with Herzog, as his statement was met with enthusiastic applause. Personally, I admired Herzog’s willingness to drop politesse a bit to (as the kids say) keep it real. In both cases, my understanding is that technically these may not be conflicts of interest; still, their completely glossing over of issues that obviously fall within the spirit of conflict of interest may speak volumes about their approach to governing.
This portion of the event was followed by a hat being passed from candidate to candidate, each selecting from it one of several issues/questions: the district’s parking situation, the district’s top problems (after parking), the district’s greatest resources, local projects in which they’ve been involved, and the permit requirement for having non-acoustic live music at “non-entertainment” establishments. After this, each candidate was allowed to speak to one of any of the other issues in the hat. Finally, they all had a chance to field (if they wished) an additional question from an audience member about how they feel concerning nearby cities choosing to be sanctuaries for illegal immigrants. Below is a helter-skelter sketch of what I took away from each candidate, based on a combination of what they said and information provided by all (save Bozeman and Sardie) in writing to a series of issues prescribed by the organizing committee and made available to the attendees.
(more…)